Valuation report rejected in due diligence: what to fix.
An investor has rejected your valuation report in due diligence. What to fix first: the rule it was prepared under, the date, the valuer, then the method.
Question about this note? Ask a partner on WhatsApp
Last updated 23 November 2026. Published by Advisory Monks Consulting.
Advisory Monks Consulting's advice when an investor rejects a valuation report: fix the three things that are cheapest to check first: the rule the report was prepared under, the date it carries, and who signed it. Then fix the method and the assumptions, and then make sure the price in the term sheet still matches the report.
A rejection is rarely about one number. The same report often has to satisfy an investor, FEMA pricing and the Companies Act, and each of them looks at different things. This note gives the order we would work in.
Advisory Monks Consulting provides tax, legal, FEMA, valuation and M&A advisory for startups, investors, NRIs and foreign companies in India. This page is general information, not advice on your facts.
On this page
Triage: what to fix, in order
| Order | What the investor or reviewer is questioning | Why it matters | What to fix | Document you need |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The report was prepared for a different rule from the one your round needs | A priced round can touch FEMA pricing for a foreign investor, the Companies Act pricing rule for a preferential offer and, for later share transfers, the fair-market-value method in Rule 57 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026 (erstwhile Rule 11UA). Each has its own requirement | List which rules apply to this round, then have the valuer confirm in the report that it meets each one | A scope paragraph in the report naming each rule |
| 2 | The report is too old for the date of issue | The FEMA pricing certificate must be not more than 90 days old at the date of investment. Under the earlier Rule 11UA, a report dated up to 90 days before the date of issue could be used; we did not find a window in the text of Rule 57 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026 on the Income Tax Department website, so confirm the position with your adviser | Check the dates against the closing timetable; if the allotment will fall outside the window, ask the valuer for an updated report | A dated report and a closing timetable |
| 3 | The valuer does not have the right credential | The Companies Act rule for preferential offers requires the price to rest on a registered valuer's report; FEMA names other eligible signatories (a chartered accountant, a SEBI-registered merchant banker and a practising cost accountant) | Confirm who is eligible under each rule that applies, and have a report issued by someone who is | The valuer's registration or membership details |
| 4 | The method does not suit the company | A discounted cash flow model on a pre-revenue company, or a net asset method on an asset-light one, invites a challenge | Ask the valuer to state why the method was chosen and to run a cross-check with a second method | A method note and a cross-check |
| 5 | The projections are unsupported | Reviewers test the forecast against actual trading and the board's plan | Tie the forecast to the board-approved budget and to signed customer or pipeline evidence, and add a sensitivity table | The board-approved plan; a sensitivity table |
| 6 | The discount rate and the peer set | Both move the value sharply, so reviewers ask how they were built | Document the discount rate build-up and why each peer was chosen or excluded | A discount-rate schedule; the peer list with reasons |
| 7 | Discounts applied or not applied (for lack of marketability, minority) | A discount that is unexplained, or inconsistent with how the instrument is priced, is easy to attack | State whether a discount was applied, on what basis, and why that fits the security being issued | A paragraph in the report |
| 8 | The issue price does not match the report | For a preferential offer, the price cannot be less than the price determined on the registered valuer's report (Rule 13(3) of the Share Capital Rules) | Reprice the round, or obtain a new report that supports the agreed price | The term sheet and the report side by side |
| 9 | The instrument's terms are not reflected | A CCPS or CCD conversion mechanism that the model ignores will change the share count | Update the model to the signed instrument and reconcile it to the cap table | The signed instrument; the reconciled cap table |
Rows 1 to 3 are checks on paper, and you can finish them without re-running the model. Rows 4 to 7 are judgment calls the valuer has to defend. Rows 8 and 9 usually decide whether the round can close at the agreed price.
When you need a fresh report
- The date has moved outside the window. Row 2: the allotment now falls after the period the rule allows.
- A material event has happened. A new round, a signed contract, a loss of a major customer or a change in the plan since the report date.
- The purpose has changed. A report prepared for one purpose is not automatically a report for a FEMA filing or a preferential allotment; ask the valuer to confirm the scope in writing.
- A US entity is involved. An Indian report does not replace a US valuation. Under Section 409A of the US Internal Revenue Code, a mis-handled valuation for stock options can expose the option holder to an additional 20 per cent federal tax plus interest. Our Rule 57 and 409A insight sets out how the two valuations fit together.
How long the fix takes
Our valuation practice page gives a typical timeline of 1 to 3 weeks for a straightforward valuation for a priced round. A complicated structure takes longer, and the date window above runs against your closing timetable, so start the fix as soon as the investor raises the point.
How Advisory Monks Consulting helps
We review the rejected report against each rule that applies to your round, tell you which of the nine points above are the real objection, and coordinate a corrected or fresh report through the credentialed valuers on our panel. Engagements start with a 20-minute diagnostic that ends in a written scope and a fixed monthly fee, and we respond with an option analysis and an indicative fee within five working days of the initial discussion; see our pricing page. For the step before a round, see our pre-Series A cap table checklist; for the wider round documents, see our SSA and SHA insight; to talk to us, book a discovery call.
Frequently asked questions
What should I fix first if an investor rejects my valuation report?
Check the rule the report was prepared under, its date and the valuer's credential before anything else. These three can be confirmed from the document itself, and a defect in any of them cannot be argued away by explaining the model.
Can one report serve FEMA, the Companies Act and the Income-tax Rules?
Sometimes, but not automatically. FEMA, the Companies Act and the Income-tax Rules each have their own pricing or valuation requirement and name different eligible signatories, so ask the valuer to state in the report which rules it meets, and have the FEMA pricing certificate dated within its window.
Does a US 409A valuation replace the Indian valuation report?
No. The two valuations answer different legal questions in different countries, and a company with both an Indian entity and a US parent usually needs both, built on one consistent enterprise value. Our valuation practice page explains the difference.
Sources
All sources were read on 23 November 2026.
- 26 U.S. Code § 409A (additional 20 per cent tax and premium interest): law.cornell.edu
- Companies (Share Capital and Debentures) Rules, 2014, Rule 13 (preferential offers; price by registered valuer's report; Rule 13(3)), as published on SEBI's website: sebi.gov.in
- Income Tax Department, Income-tax Rules, 2026, Rule 57 (determination of fair market value): incometaxindia.gov.in
- CBDT press release on the 2023 amendment of Rule 11UA (the earlier rule, for reference): pib.gov.in
- Advisory Monks Consulting, India entry for foreign companies (FEMA pricing certificate: chartered accountant, SEBI-registered merchant banker or practising cost accountant, not more than 90 days old at the date of investment, with the primary sources cited there)
- Advisory Monks Consulting, Valuation Advisory (Rule 57, FEMA Rule 21 pricing, 409A, typical timelines)
General information, not tax or legal advice. Deadlines and rules change; confirm against the official source before acting.
This note is general guidance, not tax or legal advice. Positions depend on your specific facts — speak with a partner before acting.
Does this apply to your situation? Ask a partner directly. A short message is enough to start.